baking with logo_correct
pin with logo 2

Home Ps

Now Baking In



Magic City Baking Company is a small batch bakery providing handcrafted goods, mixing nostalgia and quality, for a unique and satisfying experience.

bg image


Born out of a desire to recreate the joys of indulging in an occasional sweet treat as a child, April Sibley created Magic City Baking Company to share those experiences with others.  Her first project was a birthday cake to celebrate her daughter’s 3rd birthday and quickly turned into requests to help others celebrate momentous occasions.


Using the freshest ingredients, we aim to create quality products. Because we believe every experience is a memorable one, each baked good prepared by Magic City Baking Company is made with love. We hope that you enjoy all that Magic City Baking Company has to offer.



Hand Crafted Specialties

Cake Pops

Cake on a stick. A convenient treat available in flavors such as strawberry, lemon, birthday cake, and more!

Cookie Pops

Enjoy your chocolate (or vanilla) creme sandwich cookies dipped in your choice of white or milk chocolate. Jazz it up with sprinkles or a chocolate swirl that is sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.


The perfect sized serving of cake and always a crowd favorite, these single serve treats are meant to be shared. Flavors include vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, strawberry, and others upon request.

Wafer Cakes

Cake in the form of a cookie, wafer cakes combine your favorite cake flavor with a cookie base, transforming your tastebuds into a satisfying experience. Flavors include Italian Cream, Lemon, German Chocolate, amongst others.


Creamy and indulgent, enjoy this simply as New York Style or try a holiday favorite such as sweet potato or caramel apple crumble.

Cookie Sandwiches

Take your favorite cookie and add another to it with a cream filling and you have a cookie sandwich! Chocolate chip, sugar, and oatmeal cream are just a few of the flavors that you can enjoy.

Cinnamon Rolls

Made overnight with a buttermilk recipe, these rolls are the ultimate experience of cinnamon and sugar. Topped with a cream cheese icing while piping hot, the gooey deliciousness that ensues will leave you coming back for more!


From cream cheese pound cake to chocolate overload, our cakes are moist and decadent. Flavors are available upon request.



If you would like to find out more about Magic City Baking Company, or place an order, please drop us a note.

Email address:
Phone:  205 253 8830

Social Bar